Best Stuffing Balls

You’ll want to save this one for the upcoming holidays!

“This is an heirloom recipe made by many members of my family. It can be made ahead of the holidays and the balls frozen. One less job at the end. We always formed the stuffing into balls so they were easy to serve individually, easy to grab a cold stuffing ball as leftovers. My Grandma made extra to freeze and use for stuffed chicken breasts later. Grandma always said to try and get a little bit (a speck) of poultry seasoning on each piece of bread. If you like to stuff a bird with it, just place the stuffing balls in the cavity loosely.” ~charlie #5


2 loaves white bread

2 eggs

1 C. milk

1 C. water

1/4 C. butter

2 Stalks celery, chopped

1 Large onion, chopped

1 Small green pepper, chopped (optional)

Salt, to taste

Pepper, to taste

1/4 C fresh parsley, chopped

2 Tsps. ground sage

1-1/2-2 Tsps. poultry seasoning

Turkey broth


Open the loaves of bread and allow the bread to get stale for a day.

Tear the bread into 1-1/2″ pieces including the crusts.

Beat the eggs with the milk and water; sparingly, drizzle this mixture over the bread and mix it in just to moisten.

Saute the celery, onions, and green pepper in the butter until translucent. Salt and pepper to taste.

Add the warm celery and butter mixture tooo the bread.

Add the parsley and sprinkle in a little rubbed sage.

Cover lightly with poultry seasoning.

Gently toss with your hands.

Gently push the stuffing mixture into the corner of your mixing pan and allow to sit for 30 mins to absorb the liquid in the bread.

Form the stuffing into smaaall balls similar to a baseball.

You may freeze the balls at this point by arranging on a baking sheet and flash freezing.

When frozen, place stuffing balls in the bread bag wrappers.

When ready to bake, place balls in a 9*13-inches pan with about 1/4″ hot broth in the bottom of the pan.

You can bake them frozen or defrosted, adjust your time accordingly.

Bake at 350ºF for about 30 mins, basting a few times until browned.